Kilwins old-fashioned confectionary shop selling chocolates, handmade sweets & gift baskets

A Sweet Tooth’s Guide

Get your sweet treat fix in Sarasota with a guide to sinful, local chocolate, donut, and cool goodie purveyors

Nothing compares to a sweet treat. To celebrate, as a gift, or for no reason but to bring joy, you deserve a treat today. Follow your heart – and taste buds – to the sugary goodies of your wildest desires. Whether you’re searching to indulge in local chocolate, artisan donuts, or a unique cool treat, Sarasota’s delectable delights abound. 

Chocolate Shops & Chocolatiers

Dark, milk, white, candied, crushed, dipped, and drizzled—whichever your guilty pleasure, Sarasota chocolatiers have the packaged treats to satisfy your sweet-tooth

 

Dulcefina Chocolate and Sweets

A premier local and imported chocolate and sweets store, Dulcefina carries a vast assortment of chocolates and candies wall-to-wall from all over the world, as well as serving coffee and cappuccinos.  

 

Noela Chocolate Boutique

A chic, artisan chocolate shop in the heart of downtown Sarasota, Noela uses the finest chocolate and ingredients from around the world to create seasonal flavors and collections. Boxed selections range from fun to fancy and always with a personal touch.  

 

Norman Love Confections

Located at the shopping mecca of University Town Center, find hand-painted gourmet chocolate from acclaimed chef Norman Love. From bonbons, truffles and chocolate bars, Norman’s come beautifully packaged, preservative-free and guaranteed to wow.  

 

Pavé Chocolatier

A hidden neighborhood gem, Pavé's luxury, European gourmet chocolates range from milk chocolate, dark chocolate, white chocolate and chocolate mixed with nuts uniquely wrapped in handcrafted packaging—a delightful surprise along with of its other fine gifts you leave with for your special someone.  

 

The Chocolate Bark Company

This South Sarasota shop has an avid local following for its delicious chocolate bark, best described as a big chocolate bar with an array of other ingredients mixed and baked in such as roasted nuts, sea salt, candies or dried fruit.

 

Kilwins Chocolates, Fudge & Ice Cream

Starting with bricks of chocolate as the foundation, Kilwins makes over 75 different hand-crafted products. From clusters and barks to brittles, sea foam, turtles and truffles, Kilwins makes it all by hand. Find this famous family-owned confectionary at St. Armands Circle, Siesta Key, Venice, and the new Waterside Place in Lakewood Ranch.  

 

Gabriella Chocolates & Confections

If you happen to be in the North Venice area, make your way to Gabriella’s for some red-hearted treats. From a dark chocolate heat tower to the classic box of assorted chocolates that come in the shape of a heart, this quaint family confectionary embraces the essence of chocolate gifting. Their functional chocolate line combines chocolate with health and beauty benefits – smoother skin from eating chocolate? Yes, please!

 

Donut Shops & Bakeries

Several local joints are serving up a unique spin on the sweet treat, while others have taken the classic to a whole new level. From cake donuts to yeast donuts, bear claws to long Johns, we’ve sampled donuts from all over town and compiled a list of our very favorites.

 

Der Dutchman

Known for its hearty and traditional Amish family meals, Der Dutchman is home to one of the biggest buffets in town. In addition to their staggering buffet options, the restaurant also features a sizable bakery complete with cakes, pies, and our favorite - donuts! Their donut assortment features cake and yeast donuts as well as apple fritters and long Johns the length of your forearm. While each of their selections is stellar, we are particularly in love with their caramel long John with its cool and surprisingly light filling. Head over to the historic Pinecraft neighborhood to secure yours.

 

RONC Donuts

With two Sarasota locations, RONC Donuts, NY Bagels, Sandwiches & Coffee is a donut lover’s haven for the sweet and savory combined. Grab a cappuccino or latte and have your pick at the daily selection of fresh donuts, from glazed to sugared to sprinkled, in a variety of scrumptious flavors. The best part – if someone tagging along doesn't have much of a sweet tooth, there are plenty of savory bagel options at RONC to satisfy the craving for baked dough with a hole. 

 

Yummie's Donuts & BBQ

Angel Cream donuts and huge apple fritters are just the tip of the icing-berg at Yummie's Donuts & BBQ. Located in Venice, Yummie's is locally revered for its sweet and savory mix of scratch-made donuts and slow-smoked pulled pork. Dessert lovers will be pleased to find an ever-changing menu selection of new specialty, gourmet donut flavors such as Creme Brulé Vanilla Custard and Guinness Stout.

 

Five-O Donut Co.

Freeze! You have the right to remain silent and enjoy the creative selections at this cop-themed donut shop in downtown Sarasota. Playing off the age-old cliché of cops and donuts, this bakery opened its doors walking distance from the county courthouse and police station and has been consistently enjoyed by civilians and law enforcement alike. They are cranking out the classics like glazed, sprinkle, and chocolate-dipped, but truly shine with their specialty flavors. You’ll find cinnamon toast crunch, cherry cheesecake, cookie dough, and cronuts, and that’s just the beginning of their crazy flavor combinations. These donuts are as photogenic as they are delicious, so head over for a social media share that will surely make your friends jealous.

 

OfKors Bakery

OfKors Bakery offers standard yeast donuts with typical toppings, but it’s their brioche donuts that truly stand out. Made with rich and buttery brioche dough, each donut is piped with Bavarian cream and fruit fillings inside. They also feature atypical flavors like guava, peach, kiwi, and tiramisu. In addition to the fabulous fillings each donut is decorated with simple and dainty flourishes one would expect to find in a European bakery.

 

Peachy’s Baking Co.

The menu at Peachy’s showcases the perfection of simplicity. Typically consisting of four or five items, Peachy’s Amish-style yeast doughnut selection features their light and made-before-your-eyes creations, topped with glaze, ganache, and flavors of the day. After building a fan base with their food truck, they’ve since opened two locations in Sarasota, while the food truck continues to bring their dreamy donuts across the country to State Fairs. Gotta spread the love!

Ice Cream, Frozen Treats & Refreshing Drinks

It may be hotter outside, but Sarasota's sweet spots will cool you down and refresh your summer's day. There are plenty of places to go and indulge in frozen sweet treats to cool down—whether you want ice cream, a frozen daiquiri, a fruit popsicle, or yummy acai bowl.

Daiquiri Deck

There's arguably nothing better than an ice-cold frozen fruit daiquiri to escape the salt and sun after a day out on the beach! Luckily, there are Daiquiri Decks up and down our coastline (five, to be exact—spanning from Siesta Key and Lido Key to Anna Maria Island and Venice). No matter which one you end up at, you'll find the world-famous wall of daiquiri flavors behind the bar. Just a few fun cocktail flavors include the Electric Lemonade, Mighty Mango, and Dirty Banana, plus frozen classics like Frosé, Piña Colada, and Rum Runners. 

 

Wow Wow Lemonade Stand

Wow Wow has roots traced to Maui, Hawaii, having started as a humble lemonade stand and now expanding to the mainland U.S. to offer hand-crafted lemonades, acai bowls, smoothies, cold brews, and healthy options while remaining environmentally conscious at its forefront. Take your pick from acai bowls like Cacao Energy and Cold Brew Crave, or try an Almond Berry Flatbread Sandwich or Island Berry Grain Bowl. Of course, it's hard to say no to its fresh-pressed lemonades, like Butterfly Mojito and Watermelon Basil. Who says you can't have both? The sun's out here in South Florida—treat yourself to a cool down. 

 

Dream Earth Bowls

The idea behind Dream Earth Bowls traveled from Honolulu, Hawaii, to Sarasota after founder Ashley Yamamoto envisioned the concept of a natural cafe specializing in superfoods that also contributes a portion of its earnings to help fight world hunger. Refreshing and health-forward specialties include the popular Dream Earth Acai Bowl, the Vanilla Chia Pudding Acai Bowl, and freshly blended smoothies like Aloha Acai. For a caffeine pick-me-up, don't hesitate to order the Coffee Crunch Bowl, made up of coconut, cold brew, granola, peanut butter, honey, walnuts, and banana. 

 

Foxtail Coffee Co.

If you need a burst of energy while you cool down, head on over to one of our Foxtail Coffee locations (one at University Town Center and one at Wellen Park). You'll find a wide range of coffee brews, an espresso bar, and Kelly's Ice Cream (so actually, you've got more than just iced coffee to stay cool at Foxtail!). Go for an afternoon affogato for something extra sweet and creamy. Order a Peach Lemonade Iced Tea Shaker or a Root Beer Float to sip on while meandering at the nearby shops.

 

Great Heights Creamery

As the folks at Great Heights Creamery say, you'll get passionately handcrafted ice cream when you visit this newly opened ice cream shop in the growing Rosemary District sector of downtown Saraosta. Great Heights uses milk and cream from Dakin Dairy Farms in nearby Myakka City, ensuring you'll get a fresh-tasting ice cream. Choose from unique flavors like Coffee & Donuts, Oatmeal Cookie, PB & J, and Somewhere in Tuscany—the latter of which features rosemary, a touch of sea salt, and olive oil.

 

Orange Octopus

With its unique name and colorful shop, you know that Orange Octopus will make for a fun visit. Online reviewers praise the local shop for its homemade ice cream, artisan flavors, friendly staff, and quick service. Some flavor highlights include Orange (of course!), made with real Florida oranges, Super Man (sweet cream with swirls of blue, red, and yellow), and Gator Tracks (vanilla with crushed Reese's Peanut Butter cups and chocolate swirls). Or for something cool and sweet to sip on, choose a milkshake, malt, or float.  

 

Scoops Venice

Scoops Venice says on its website that it offers "ice cream in paradise," and we agree! This old-fashioned ice cream shop not only offers its fun ice cream concoctions but also has floats, milkshakes, soft serve ice cream, and gelato. Highlights include the Double Fudge Brownie Shake, the Scoops Ice Cream Sandwich, and Kids Sundaes with flavors like Dirt Cake and PB Chocolate. There are even cereal-infused ice cream bowls—yum!

 

Summer Tap Juice Bar

As the name implies, you're on tap for a cool summer when visiting Summer Tap Juice Bar, located in the Historic Burns Court area of downtown Sarasota. The local juice bar with a cozy lounge inside specializes in cold-pressed juices and fresh fruit smoothies—including the Seasonal Star Fruit, Sunshine in the Bottle, Island Papaya, Tropical Paradise, and many others. Or simmer down from the summer sun with an iced Izu Matcha tea, followed by a chilled shot of pure beet or carrot juice. 

 

3Natives Acai & Juicery

3Natives says that it's spreading its positive and healthy vibes throughout Florida—with four locations alone just in Sarasota County. The Florida-grown company continues to expand with locations throughout the Sunshine State, with a menu featuring acai bowls, smoothies made with coconut water or almond milk, salads, wraps, and toasts. For an extra wellness boost, don't miss the lineup of cold-pressed juices and shots in the fridge to take with you, like the Twisted Ginger Shot (ginger, pineapple, and honey) and the Lean'n'Green (with kale, pineapple, pear, and lime).

 

Scoops & Sprinkles

Pop onto the outdoor patio of Scoops & Sprinkles for some wholesome memory making. This quaint Pinecraft ice cream shop has developed a cult following with their locally made ice cream and waffle cones made in house daily. Fan favorites such as Cookie Butter Crunch - Cinnamon cookie ice cream with Biscoff cookies and cookie butter – are just as popular as their dairy-free options that taste equally decadent as the originals.

liz sandburg headshot for author bio
MEET THE AUTHOR

Liz Sandburg

A former Sconnie, Liz moved to Sarasota in 2005. She lives on the Phillippi Creek with her family and the world’s greatest dog.